If forgiveness is motivated by fear of divine punishment, is it really moral maturity? The Gospels complicate the modern image of a purely loving Jesus.
There’s a version of Jesus that almost everyone seems to know, including people who’ve never opened a Bible. He’s the gentle moral teacher who tells us to love our enemies, turn the other cheek, forgive endlessly, and replace the wrath and violence of the Old Testament with compassion and grace. I’ll admit… that’s a very appealing picture of Jesus and there’s certainly material in the Gospels to support it.
But there’s other material you don’t tend to see on inspirational posters or coffee mugs. Throughout the Gospels, Jesus also threatens people with Gehenna, fire, outer darkness, weeping and gnashing of teeth, and—in the passage from Matthew that we read in this week’s main episode—being handed over to torturers.
What happens to the “Gospel of Love” when we stop cherry-picking the comforting passages and read the threats alongside them? And more importantly, if we’re trying to develop genuine moral mastery, can fear of divine punishment ever really get us there?
So, let’s dive into that… in this episode of Afterthoughts!
