CODA Project
Mythologizing the Bible
From Pews to Pundits: The Crisis of Moral Outsourcing
0:00
-15:50

From Pews to Pundits: The Crisis of Moral Outsourcing

MTB Ep. 16: "Afterthoughts"

Many people believe they’ve escaped blind obedience once they leave organized religion. But have we actually stopped outsourcing our conscience… or have we simply handed it to a new set of authorities? Moral independence requires more than rejecting old dogmas; it demands the courage to think carefully, question confidently, and take responsibility for our own judgments.


In the famous Milgram experiments conducted in the 1960s, ordinary participants were instructed to deliver electric shocks to a stranger whenever that person answered a question incorrectly. The shocks weren’t real, but the participants believed they were. As the experiment progressed, the person in the chair began screaming, pleading, and eventually falling silent. The dial went all the way up to 450 volts, labeled with phrases like “danger” and “severe shock.”

And here’s the uncomfortable part: about sixty-five percent of participants (normal people, people very much like us) turned the dial all the way to the maximum level simply because an authority figure told them to continue.

They didn’t do it because they were cruel or evil. They did it because someone in a position of authority assured them the responsibility was not theirs.

In other words, they outsourced their conscience.

So, let’s dive into that… in this episode of Afterthoughts!

CODA Project is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?